Section 1782 Discovery of Documents Located Outside the United States: The Control Requirement

By Jorge Schmidt, Legal Schmidt PLLC · Published June 21, 2026 · Last updated November 2, 2026

On May 12, 2026, in Courtroom 18B of the federal courthouse at 500 Pearl Street in Manhattan, the fund that says it owns the Finance Tower in Brussels asked Judge Denise L. Cote to order an American PIMCO company to hand over documents held by its European affiliate. But she refused, and a month later a second judge refused again, for the same reason.

The issue: Does corporate affiliation, without more, establish the “possession, custody, or control” needed to order discovery under Section 1782? On this record, both judges said no. Judges in that court read control to mean “a practical ability” or “legal right to obtain” the documents, and both held that the fund had not shown the American company met that test for files held by what Judge Cote called “a separately incorporated European affiliate.”

The Finance Tower in Brussels, a tall office tower with a blue glass facade and pale vertical ribs, shown in full from street level across a road under a cloudy sky, set on a dark background.
The Finance Tower in Brussels, July 21, 2018. Photo: Wikimedia Commons (CC0). Cropped.

A tower, a valuation and a lawsuit in the U.K.

The fund, Tour des Finances NV GVBF, says it bought the Finance Tower and neighboring properties in 2020 for more than €1.2 billion, partly with loans from a group of lenders that included Allianz entities. CBRE acted as agent for the lenders. PIMCO Prime Real Estate GmbH (“PIMCO Europe”), a European PIMCO affiliate, managed investments for those Allianz lenders.

Excerpt from the fund’s memorandum of law filed May 7, 2026, with the sentence stating that it purchased the Finance Tower and adjoining properties in 2020 for over 1.2 billion euros highlighted.
The fund’s own account of the purchase. Memorandum of law, ECF No. 5 (S.D.N.Y. May 7, 2026), at 1.

According to the fund, PIMCO Europe and Legal & General, both on the lenders’ side, tried to drive down the building’s appraised value. It alleges that they applied “undue pressure” on the appraiser Knight Frank to cut its December 2025 appraisal of about €1.081 billion to below €950 million, and that Knight Frank resigned on February 3, 2026. On April 16, 2026, it sued CBRE, the lenders’ agent, in the High Court of Justice in the United Kingdom. The PIMCO companies are not parties to that case. PIMCO Prime Real Estate LLC (“PIMCO US”), the American affiliate, told the New York court that it made no loan to the fund and had no role in the appraisals. The fund’s accusations are unproven.

The law, and the phrase that decided the case

Section 1782 is a short federal law that lets someone involved in a case abroad ask an American judge to order people and companies here to hand over documents or testify.

On May 7, 2026, the fund applied in New York for an order against PIMCO US, whose listed corporate parents include Allianz SE and Pacific Investment Management Company LLC. The parties agreed the statute’s threshold requirements were met. Judges then weigh four factors from Intel Corp. v. Advanced Micro Devices, Inc., 542 U.S. 241 (2004). Here the only one in dispute was whether the subpoena was “unduly intrusive or burdensome.”

Text card quoting 28 U.S.C. § 1782(a), with the words in accordance with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure highlighted.
The phrase that brings in the ordinary discovery rules. 28 U.S.C. § 1782(a), text from the Cornell Legal Information Institute.

The statute says documents are produced “in accordance with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure,” and the control test comes from Rules 34 and 45. The applicant must prove control. As Judge Torres’s June order noted, quoting a 2024 decision of the same court, In re Boustany: “The party seeking discovery has the burden of showing that the other party has control over the material sought and, if they fail to do so, the court’s § 1782 analysis need go no further.”

The first hearing

The granite entrance of the Daniel Patrick Moynihan United States Courthouse, with bronze doors, the building’s name carved above them and the street number 500 beside them.
The entrance of the Daniel Patrick Moynihan U.S. Courthouse, 500 Pearl Street, May 17, 2012. Photo: Ken Lund, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0. Cropped.

At the May 12 hearing, Judge Cote treated control as an issue distinct from burden and found that the fund had not shown it. According to the transcript, as quoted in the June order, she said the fund had not cited “a case in which one corporate affiliate in America has been required under . . . the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 34 and Rule 45, to produce the documents of a foreign affiliate when both affiliates are separately incorporated.” Her written order the next day left the door open.

Excerpt from Judge Cote’s order of May 13, 2026, with the paragraph denying the application without prejudice to a renewed application highlighted.
Denied, with permission to try again. Order, ECF No. 20 (S.D.N.Y. May 13, 2026).

The ruling

The fund renewed its petition on May 16 in the same case, No. 26-mc-213. On May 18, Judge Cote set a briefing schedule and ordered that argument take place “before the Honorable Analisa Torres.” The docket does not say why. The case had been assigned at opening to Judge Katherine Polk Failla, who signed none of its orders, and no reassignment, recusal or related-case order appears. Judge Torres decided without oral argument. The new subpoena sought documents involving three PIMCO Europe employees about the disputed valuation and PIMCO Europe’s part in a transaction abroad.

Judge Analisa Torres, wearing glasses and a pearl necklace, speaking into a microphone.
Analisa Torres at a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on judicial nominations, January 23, 2013. Image: U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee (archived hearing page), Wikimedia Commons, public domain. Cropped.

On June 15, 2026, Judge Torres denied the renewed petition because the fund had not shown that the American company controlled the documents. She described PIMCO Europe as “a corporate affiliate of PIMCO US, but an otherwise distinct business entity.” The decision is In re Ex Parte Application of Tour des Finances NV GVBF, No. 26 Misc. 213 (S.D.N.Y. June 15, 2026). Zachary Gerber, PIMCO US’s compliance director, had sworn that the three employees “do not work with the investment teams that work for [PIMCO US],” that “no employee of [PIMCO US] has access to any of [these individuals’] email mailboxes or business records,” which sit on servers in the European Union, and that, to the best of his knowledge, no one at PIMCO US had the authority to direct the European company to share its information. Judge Torres called this “new, more robust evidence.”

Excerpt from Judge Torres’s order of June 15, 2026, with the sentence denying the application because the fund had not shown possession, custody, or control highlighted.
The holding. Order, ECF No. 40 (S.D.N.Y. June 15, 2026), at 6.

The fund argued that control was not its burden, citing two recent Second Circuit decisions, In re SBK ART LLC, 168 F.4th 68 (2d Cir. 2026), and Banoka S.a.r.l. v. Elliott Management Corp., 148 F.4th 54 (2d Cir. 2025). Judge Torres wrote that the fund “misreads” them. In SBK, she wrote, there appears to have been no dispute that the law firm, Akin Gump, had access to the documents, and SBK “does not do away with the requirement that the documents be in the target’s possession or control.” The fund read Banoka to forbid requirements beyond the statute itself. The judge answered that the control requirement “comes directly from § 1782’s text, which incorporates by reference the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.”

The judge also refused the fund’s fallback request for a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition of PIMCO US, with Gerber as its witness. Discovery used “solely to determine the extent of PIMCO US’s potential access” was not shown to be “for use” abroad, and the request rested on “little more than speculation,” which made it unduly burdensome under the fourth Intel factor.

Documents abroad are not the problem

The files’ location did not decide the case. In Sergeeva v. Tripleton Int’l Ltd., 834 F.3d 1194 (11th Cir. 2016), a Russian woman tracing assets she alleged her former husband was hiding won an order against an Atlanta company for documents held by its Bahamas affiliate, because circumstantial evidence, including that the Bahamas company supplied the Atlanta company with client information, showed control. The Eleventh Circuit agreed that the location of documents “does not establish a per se bar to discovery under § 1782,” and called the limit the “Control Requirement.” In In re del Valle Ruiz, 939 F.3d 520 (2d Cir. 2019), the Second Circuit said the same: “there is no per se bar to the extraterritorial application of § 1782.”

The difference is proof. In Sergeeva, the record showed the companies shared the information. In New York, PIMCO US’s sworn evidence said the opposite. For an applicant, the practical point is to name the company that holds the documents, or to prove with evidence that the named company can get them, before filing.

What happened to the fund

Tour des Finances lost both petitions in New York and its request for a deposition. Through entry 42, the docket shows no appeal; its last entries, on July 2, 2026, record the filing of the May 12 hearing transcript. For the full framework, see A Practical Guide to Bringing and Defending Section 1782 Applications.

How this page cites the filings

Rulings and quotations come from the filed orders of May 13 and June 15, 2026 (ECF Nos. 20 and 40), and the account of the tower and the valuation from the fund’s memorandum (ECF No. 5) and PIMCO US’s opposition (ECF No. 16), all read in free copies in CourtListener’s RECAP archive. The corporate parents come from the docket text of ECF No. 14, the hearing details from ECF No. 8, and the move to Judge Torres from the orders at ECF Nos. 31 and 35. Sergeeva and del Valle Ruiz were read in the courts’ published opinions. Docket: CourtListener RECAP docket, entries from May 7, 2026 (entry 1), last entry 42 (July 2, 2026), pulled November 2, 2026; PACER Monitor’s public docket showed the same last entry when pulled the same day. PACER was not checked.