Tracing Assets Through US Banks With Section 1782

By Jorge Schmidt, Legal Schmidt PLLC · Published June 28, 2026 · Last updated November 14, 2026

In 2008, Damien James Byrne, an Irish national living in the United Arab Emirates, and his father paid a company, Seven Seas Computers LLC, about $7.1 million in exchange for ownership of a residential building that was to be built in Abu Dhabi. In 2021 a Dubai appeals court found three people tied to the company personally liable for fraud and entered a judgment of about $9.5 million. Byrne said some of the money had moved through New York, so in February 2023 he asked a federal judge in Manhattan to order 13 financial institutions to produce wire transfer records. One of those three people, Mehboob Hamza Khetty Dawoodbhoy, came to court to stop him. On May 2, 2023, Judge Valerie Caproni let the subpoenas stand and refused to give Dawoodbhoy copies of what the banks produced.

The issue: Can someone holding a foreign judgment use Section 1782 to make American banks produce records of where the money went, and does the person being pursued get to see them? On the record in Byrne, Judge Caproni said yes to the first question and no to the second. A later case in the same court shows that the bank itself must be reachable in New York, because it is at home there or because a specific transfer is tied to its New York operations.

Valerie Caproni, wearing glasses, a gray jacket and a black turtleneck, seated at a microphone, with people seated behind her.
Valerie Caproni at a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on judicial nominations, May 23, 2013. Image: U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee (archived hearing page), Wikimedia Commons, public domain. Cropped.

A Dubai judgment and an order of arrest

According to the judge’s opinion, Byrne said the three, who were current or former shareholders or managers of the company, “used the funds for personal and unintended uses.” The Dubai judgment was affirmed by the Court of Cassation, and on April 14, 2022, the Execution Court “ordered the arrest of the Liable Parties (until payment is made in full).” Byrne also planned to file a criminal complaint in Sharjah “once he has sufficient evidence to persuade the Public Prosecutor that a prosecution will be successful.” Dawoodbhoy told the court he had “no full and open knowledge” of the 2008 deal.

The law Byrne used

Section 1782 is a short federal law that lets someone involved in a case abroad ask an American judge to order people and companies here to hand over documents or testify.

Text card quoting 28 U.S.C. § 1782(a), with the words to produce a document or other thing for use in a proceeding in a foreign or international tribunal highlighted.
28 U.S.C. § 1782(a), text from the Cornell Legal Information Institute.

Byrne asked for records of wire transfers in which the banks acted as originating, beneficiary, intermediary or correspondent bank, from 2016 on, involving a list of people and companies he believed had received the money. Judge Caproni granted the application on February 27, 2023, four days after it was filed. Dawoodbhoy then moved to intervene, to vacate the order and to quash the subpoenas. None of the banks moved against the subpoenas. As the judge put it, “financial institutions frequently receive discovery requests of this ilk and rarely oppose them.”

The ruling

The judge let Dawoodbhoy intervene, because he had privacy interests in records of money moving to or from him. Then she denied the rest. Because Byrne was already pursuing enforcement in Dubai, she held, the records were for use in a foreign proceeding, and Byrne, “actively attempting to enforce a judgment,” was an interested person. She found the time period “proportionate to the needs of the case, which involves a yearslong effort to avoid the enforcement of an outstanding multi-million-dollar judgment.”

Dawoodbhoy’s fallback was a copy of everything the banks produced. Citing United States v. Miller, the judge noted that bank customers have no reasonable expectation of privacy in records their banks keep. She accepted Byrne’s argument that there was a substantial risk that, given access, Dawoodbhoy would tip off the others “so that they can again reconfigure their financial arrangements and move money to avoid paying the judgments.” Nothing stopped him from requesting records of his own transactions from the banks.

Excerpt from Judge Caproni’s opinion of May 2, 2023, with the passage finding a substantial risk that the intervenor would tip off the other liable parties highlighted.
Judge Caproni’s finding on the risk of a tip-off. Opinion and Order, ECF No. 15 (S.D.N.Y. May 2, 2023), at 12.

The decision is In re Byrne, No. 23 Misc. 48, 2023 WL 3203811 (S.D.N.Y. May 2, 2023). The judge closed the case the same day.

The bank must be reachable

The banks in Byrne did not contest that they were in the district. Others have. Golden Meditech Holdings, a Hong Kong company, sued eight defendants in Hong Kong’s High Court, alleging they secretly moved money owed to it out of an escrow account, including $429 million, and falsified bank records to hide it. The accusations are unproven. In January 2024 it asked a federal court in Manhattan for records from 14 banks.

The High Court building in Hong Kong, a white multi-story building with the words The High Court in English and Chinese on its facade, beside a street with tram tracks and a footbridge, with the Bank of China Tower behind it.
The High Court building in Hong Kong, November 5, 2023. Photo: LN9267, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Cropped.

Quoting the Second Circuit, Judge Dale E. Ho wrote that the statute’s “resides or is found” language “extends to the limits of personal jurisdiction consistent with due process.” He granted the request for seven banks headquartered in Manhattan and at first denied it for seven others. On renewal, he found three more at home in New York. Commerzbank, incorporated in Germany, was not: its New York branch serves as its U.S. headquarters, and the judge found it not clear that its presence extended beyond a “primary office” here.

Dale E. Ho, wearing glasses, a dark suit and a patterned tie, speaking at a microphone behind a name card reading Mr. Dale E. Ho, set on a dark background.
Dale E. Ho at a Senate Judiciary Committee nominations hearing, December 1, 2021. Image: U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee (archived hearing page), Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

For the rest, the question was specific jurisdiction. Quoting the Second Circuit’s decision in In re del Valle Ruiz, Judge Ho asked whether the bank’s use of New York was “the primary or proximate reason that the evidence sought is available at all.” Bank of China’s New York branch qualified, because a defendant held an account there and Golden Meditech pointed to a specific $429 million transfer that may have gone through it. Wells Fargo and Bank of America did not. It was not enough that some Hong Kong banks use their New York branches for dollar transfers.

Excerpt from Judge Ho’s order of December 30, 2024, with the sentence finding no specific jurisdiction over Wells Fargo and Bank of America highlighted.
Judge Ho’s finding on Wells Fargo and Bank of America. Order, ECF No. 57 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 30, 2024), at 8.

The decision is In re Golden Meditech Holdings Ltd., No. 24 Misc. 24, 2024 WL 5247285 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 30, 2024). Judge Ho also found requests for “logs or spreadsheets” of wire transfers from February 2017 on not “plainly overbroad.” He rejected, for lack of any showing, the defendants’ claim that the evidence was really meant for an arbitration, quoting In re Accent Delight: the statute does not prevent “using the discovery elsewhere unless the district court orders otherwise.”

The brick facade of a Bank of China office on Madison Avenue, with the bank’s name in gold letters above three arched doorways, pedestrians on the sidewalk and a yellow taxi passing.
A Bank of China office on Madison Avenue in Manhattan, February 2007. Photo: David Shankbone, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.5. Cropped.

Who gets told

In his first order, Judge Ho quoted the Second Circuit: “[I]t is neither uncommon nor improper for district courts to grant applications made pursuant to § 1782 ex parte,” because the respondent can move to quash later. In In re Application of AbbVie Logistics B.V., No. 26 Misc. 284 (S.D.N.Y. June 23, 2026), Judge Jesse M. Furman authorized a subpoena to the New York branch of Standard Chartered and the New York agency of National Bank of Kuwait “without prejudice to the timely filing of a motion to quash.” Before serving it, AbbVie had to give notice to “the party or parties against whom the requested discovery is likely to be used.” The order does not name the foreign case, and the docket shows a certificate of service filed on July 9, 2026.

What happened to Byrne

Byrne’s subpoenas survived, and the man he was pursuing did not get copies of what the banks produced. The docket does not show what the banks turned over or whether Byrne collected anything, and it shows no appeal. In Golden Meditech, the docket’s last entry, in April 2025, is an order on motions to seal the briefs. For the full framework, see A Practical Guide to Bringing and Defending Section 1782 Applications.

How this page cites the filings

Facts and quotations come from the orders themselves, read in free copies in CourtListener’s RECAP archive and checked against Midpage’s text: in Byrne, ECF Nos. 7 and 15; in Golden Meditech, ECF Nos. 8 and 57; in AbbVie, ECF No. 8. Miller, del Valle Ruiz and Accent Delight are described as those orders quote them. Docket: CourtListener RECAP docket, entries from February 23, 2023 (entry 1), last entry 16 (August 29, 2023), pulled November 2, 2026. Docket: CourtListener RECAP docket, entries from January 16, 2024 (entry 1), last entry 58 (April 23, 2025), pulled November 2, 2026. Docket: CourtListener RECAP docket, entries from June 9, 2026 (entry 1), last entry 11 (July 23, 2026), pulled November 2, 2026. PACER was not checked.