Does the foreign proceeding have to be pending already?

By Jorge Schmidt, Legal Schmidt PLLC · Published August 6, 2026 · Last updated November 15, 2026

No: in Intel Corp. v. Advanced Micro Devices, Inc., 542 U.S. 241, 258–259 (2004), the Supreme Court held that the foreign proceeding need not be “pending” or “imminent”; it is enough that the proceeding is within reasonable contemplation. What that still requires is a concrete showing, as two Southern District of New York decisions issued one day apart in July 2026 illustrate: In re Hanna was denied because the applicant named no specific claims or legal theory, while Alerte Congolaise, which set out its claims, counsel and steps already taken, was granted.

On October 27, 2025, two Congolese nonprofits filed the same kind of request in two American cities. In New York and in Houston, Alerte Congolaise pour l’Environnement et les Droits de l’Homme and Actions pour la Promotion et Protection des Peuples et Espèces Menacés asked federal courts for evidence from winning bidders in an auction of methane gas blocks in Lake Kivu, and from people tied to them. Their case in the Democratic Republic of the Congo had not been filed. That same day, in the same New York court, a magistrate judge recommended denying a request by Victor Drake Hanna, a former executive of a mining company, who wanted Dechert LLP’s files for a lawsuit in England that he had not filed either.

The issue: How real must a foreign case be before Section 1782 can help a litigant who has not filed it yet? Real enough that a court can see the claims, the forum and the steps already taken. Hanna offered the word “imminent,” and lost. The Congolese groups set out their claims, counsel and steps already taken, and won. The two final rulings came one day apart, on July 27 and 28, 2026.

Tall stone columns along the front of a granite building, with the words United States Court House carved above them and a flag on the roof, under a gray sky.
The Thurgood Marshall United States Courthouse in Manhattan, January 13, 2023. Photo: Kidfly182, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Cropped.

The statute

Section 1782 lets a federal court order a person who “resides or is found” in its district to produce evidence “for use in a proceeding in a foreign or international tribunal.” In the Second Circuit, the applicant must show three things: the target is in the district, “the discovery is for use in a foreign proceeding before a foreign [or international] tribunal,” and the applicant is a tribunal or “any interested person.” Only then may the court weigh the discretionary factors from Intel Corp. v. Advanced Micro Devices, Inc., 542 U.S. 241 (2004).

The foreign case need not be pending. But when it does not exist yet, “for use” demands what courts call reasonable contemplation: “some concrete basis” from which a court “can determine that the contemplated proceeding is more than just a twinkle in counsel’s eye.”

Hanna: a plan without a lawsuit

Hanna filed on May 19, 2025, seeking a subpoena to Dechert. His application said he had been head of strategy and chief executive for Africa at Eurasian Natural Resources PLC (ENRC), and that Dechert partner Neil Gerrard, hired by ENRC in 2011 for an internal investigation, had made him a scapegoat. It pointed to the English High Court’s 2022 judgment for ENRC against Dechert and Gerrard. Hanna wanted to bring his own claims in England. These are his allegations.

Magistrate Judge Valerie Figueredo found that Dechert is in the district and that Hanna is an interested person. On October 27, 2025, she recommended denial anyway, because he did “not identify specific claims he intends to bring in England,” nor “offer a specific legal theory or theories under which he intends to bring those claims.” The recommendation was without prejudice to renewal.

Hanna did not object. On February 14, 2026, he filed an amended application. It added that the case would be “in tort and under data protection legislation,” called it “imminent,” and referred to an accompanying declaration from his lawyer, Paul A. Rigali. No declaration was filed. On April 6, the court told him to file it if he meant to. He did not respond.

Her second report, on April 14, listed what was still missing. Hanna “still has not indicated that he has retained English counsel to represent him in his planned litigation.” His U.S. counsel gave no sworn declaration about plans to sue. He had not sent a demand letter to Dechert or Gerrard. The new phrases were “vague descriptions of claims,” not enough to show the case was “more than just a twinkle in counsel’s eye.”

Excerpt from the magistrate judge’s second report and recommendation, with the sentence saying Hanna has not identified his claims or a legal theory highlighted.
Report and Recommendation, In re Application of Victor Drake Hanna, No. 1:25-mc-00225, ECF No. 7, at 5 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 14, 2026).

Because the statute was not met, she wrote, “the Court need not reach the discretionary Intel factors.” Hanna again filed no objection. On July 28, 2026, Judge Ronnie Abrams reviewed the report for clear error, found none and adopted it “in its entirety.” She also certified that any appeal “would not be taken in good faith” for purposes of in forma pauperis status, and closed the case. The docket shows no appeal.

Alerte Congolaise: claims, counsel and steps taken

A wide view from a hill of a lake shore lined with a dense city of red and white roofs, with green trees in the foreground and hills and clouds beyond the water.
Lake Kivu and the city of Goma, seen from a hill, May 13, 2021. Photo: Ericnkurunziza, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Cropped.

In July 2022, the DRC’s Ministry of Hydrocarbons put three methane gas blocks in Lake Kivu up for auction. On January 13, 2023, it chose the winners, including Symbion Power LLC, a power company headquartered in New York, with a local affiliate. The two groups say the auction was “characterized by an extreme lack of transparency and numerous apparent breaches of Congolese and international law,” and they plan to ask the Administrative Tribunal in Kinshasa to cancel the awards. These are their allegations.

Their Houston petition, against the winner of another block and related parties, came first: Judge Drew B. Tipton granted it on November 3, 2025. In New York, the groups chose not to proceed ex parte. Symbion opposed in February 2026, arguing the Congolese case was not within reasonable contemplation.

On July 27, 2026, Judge Paul A. Engelmayer granted the application in Alerte Congolaise pour l’Environnement et les Droits de l’Homme v. Symbion Power LLC, No. 1:25-mc-00480. Subjective intent is not enough, he wrote, but the lawsuit need not be “pending or even imminent.”

Excerpt from Judge Engelmayer’s opinion, with the sentences listing the applicants’ objective indicia highlighted.
Opinion and Order, Alerte Congolaise v. Symbion Power LLC, No. 1:25-mc-00480, ECF No. 22, at 10 (S.D.N.Y. July 27, 2026).

The groups had identified “the legal arguments that they intend to make, evidence that they envision offering, the tribunal where the case would be brought, and their counsel,” and shown standing under Congolese law. They had “written and met with Congolese authorities to acquire the official decrees allocating the gas blocks and contracts that they seek to cancel,” which the court called a predicate to filing. The Houston petition counted too: it “evidences their genuine intention to pursue the anticipated foreign proceeding.”

Symbion relied on Novalpina, where the same judge denied an applicant that could not say whether it had a viable claim. No such uncertainty existed here. The application, it held, was “far from being a fishing expedition.”

The rest of the ruling

Symbion argued it had an interest in the Congolese case, since its affiliate might be drawn in. That did not make it a participant: “[T]he mere possibility that a third party may ultimately be named in the litigation does not justify denying a third-party subpoena pursuant to Section 1782.” Documents held abroad were not categorically off-limits, under In re del Valle Ruiz, if Symbion controlled them.

Symbion also said the DRC has no pre-filing discovery. The court called that a procedural rule about timing, not a “proof-gathering” restriction. And where requests swept too broadly, the court trimmed them. It limited two document requests and one deposition topic so they would not reach records “wholly unrelated to the 2022 auction,” required a protective order for confidential and trade-secret information, and gave Symbion four weeks to produce. The judge entered the protective order on August 25, 2026.

What separated the two

Read together, the rulings list what a court looks for before the foreign case exists: named claims and a theory, a forum, counsel, sworn declarations, steps taken abroad and a filing date. Hanna’s file named a forum and little else. The Congolese file had claims, a tribunal, counsel, sworn declarations, meetings with officials and a promise to file “as soon as reasonably possible,” and a second court had already granted relief on much the same showing.

Neither docket says whether the Congolese case has been filed in Kinshasa. In Houston, the docket lists a motion to compel on August 18, 2026, oppositions in September and further filings through October 26.

The full primer on Section 1782 is at https://jorgeschmidt.com/1782/.

How this page cites the filings

The Hanna amended application (ECF No. 5), April 6 order (ECF No. 6), second report (ECF No. 7) and adoption order (ECF No. 8), the Alerte Congolaise opinion (ECF No. 22) and protective order (ECF No. 30), and the Houston order (Alerte Congolaise v. Winds Exploration & Production, LLC, No. 4:25-mc-02083, ECF No. 3) were read in CourtListener’s RECAP archive. The first Hanna report (ECF No. 4) is not in the archive; it is quoted as the adoption order quotes it. The New York opinion cites the Houston ruling as dated August 21, 2025; the Houston order itself is signed November 3, 2025, and this page uses that date. Docket: CourtListener RECAP docket, entries from May 19, 2025 (entry 1), last entry 8 (July 28, 2026), pulled November 2, 2026 (Hanna). Docket: CourtListener RECAP docket, entries from October 27, 2025 (entry 1), last entry 30 (August 25, 2026), pulled November 2, 2026 (Alerte Congolaise, New York). Docket: CourtListener RECAP docket, entries from October 27, 2025 (entry 1), last entry 31 (October 26, 2026), pulled November 2, 2026 (Alerte Congolaise, Houston). PACER was not checked.